Email Marketing for D2C Livestock Farmers, Ranchers, and Butcher Shops

podcast Dec 11, 2025

Email marketing stands as a pillar in the digital marketing world, offering an effective way to reach and retain customers. If you're eager to dive into the realm of email marketing and leverage it for your business, you're in the right place. With 15 years of experience, Katie Olthoff has compiled valuable insights that will guide you through creating a successful email marketing strategy. Let's explore the marketing funnel, the power of emails, the importance of lead magnets, and design tips to optimize your campaigns.

Understanding the Marketing Funnel

The marketing funnel illustrates the journey potential customers take—from discovering your business to making a purchase. The key stages are awareness, consideration, and decision-making. While a brick-and-mortar store might quickly convert a passerby into a customer, the digital realm requires multiple touchpoints, often facilitated by email marketing.

The Power of Email in the Digital Era

Contrary to the belief that email is outdated, statistics tell a different story. Emails boast a 40% average open rate, significantly higher than social media's reach. For instance, Facebook posts are only shown to about 4% of your followers, and Instagram to around 8%. Even small brands experience greater engagement through email, making it a vital tool for digital communication.

Getting Started with Lead Magnets

A great way to expand your email list is by offering lead magnets—a free resource enticing enough to capture potential customers' emails. Ensure your lead magnet aligns with your products and genuinely solves a problem for your audience. Think guides, recipes, or valuable discounts.

Collecting Email Addresses

Utilize online and offline methods to grow your list. Promote lead magnets on social media, employ website popups, and offer easy signup options at points of sale. In-person events, use QR codes or a simple clipboard to gather emails without slowing traffic.

The Welcome Email: Making a Great First Impression

Once you have a new subscriber, send a welcome email promptly. This email should include your promised lead magnet, introduce your business, highlight your products, and set expectations for future communications. Engaging your audience early fosters trust and encourages participation.

Types of Emails to Send

Regular emails should not only pitch sales but offer value and build trust. Consider a mix of informative newsletters and high-impact flyer-style emails. While newsletters can provide recipes and farm updates, flyer emails should focus on specific promotions or events, driving clear action from the recipient.

Designing for Engagement

Design emails with mobile users in mind—over 70% of users read emails on their phones. Keep content concise and utilize short paragraphs, bold text, and bullet points to enhance readability. Effective design captures attention and encourages engagement.

Leveraging Social Proof and Testimonials

Include customer reviews and visuals showcasing your bustling business. This social proof reinforces your credibility and encourages new and existing customers to engage with your offerings.

Crafting Compelling Subject Lines

To stand out in a crowded inbox, your subject lines should evoke curiosity or urgency. Phrases that suggest exclusivity or invite intrigue, such as "Last chance to save!" or "Guess where I was this week," can significantly boost open rates.

Automating for Efficiency

Once your email strategy is in place, consider automation. Craft welcome sequences for new subscribers and set up automated reminders for abandoned carts. These processes ensure consistent communication without constant manual input.

Mastering email marketing requires a thoughtful approach, combining strong content, appealing design, and strategic timing. Start small with your campaigns, draw from the tips shared here, and watch your engagement and conversions grow. Email marketing is not just alive; it's thriving for those who understand how to use it effectively. If you're interested in learning more, consider further educating yourself with courses that delve deeper into these strategies. Happy emailing!

This free webinar is taught by ChopLocal's Katie Olthoff, a farmer and former teacher with over 10 years of experience using email marketing in food and agriculture.

For more FREE resources to help you sell more meat:

- Subscribe to our email newsletter at https://mailchi.mp/choplocal/choplocal-university

- Follow us @ ChopLocal University on Facebook and/or Instagram

- Catch the course mentioned in this episode here: http://choplocaluniversity.com/email-marketing

Stay connected with news and updates!

Join our email list for the latest tools and tips to help you sell more meat online!

Don't worry, your information will not be shared.

We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.